The legal profession holds a respected and responsible position in society, where the role of lawyers extends beyond offering legal advice—it plays a crucial part in strengthening the very foundation of the justice system. In this context, adherence to “Professional Ethics” becomes a moral necessity for lawyers.
In today’s era, where even the legal profession is increasingly being viewed through a commercial lens, the question becomes even more relevant: Should there be a codified act to ensure ethical conduct in the legal profession? Additionally, it’s important to understand which existing enactments currently govern professional ethics in law. This article delves into these aspects in detail.
Table of Contents
What is the need for professional ethics in the legal profession? Is there a necessity for a codified act regarding professional ethics?
(A) Need for the Codification of Professional Ethics in the Legal Profession
In the modern era, where financial gain is increasingly emphasized in the legal profession, there has been a noticeable decline in ethical standards. Lawyers are beginning to stray from their duties, and there is a rise in cases of contempt of court. In such circumstances, to keep the administration of justice clean, pure, and untainted, it becomes imperative to codify professional ethics in the legal field.
To understand the necessity of codifying professional ethics, we must first understand why such ethics are essential and whether the behavior of legal practitioners can be regulated through a codified set of rules.
The American Bar Association, in addressing the question of the need for a code of professional ethics, presented the following arguments:
Just as justice on Earth serves as a means to protect human interests, lawyers are the high priests in the temple of justice. The purity and credibility of justice depend on the ethical standards upheld by lawyers. The integrity and morality of lawyers are foundational to the purity of justice delivery.
With the evolving traits of modern society, law too has undergone a complex transformation. As law develops, so do the means and opportunities available to lawyers—provided they maintain ethical conduct. Hence, consistent guiding principles are essential to steer legal professionals on the right path and deter unethical behavior. A lawyer who declines in moral character can cause the downfall of judicial and legal institutions.
A code of ethics can particularly guide new entrants into the profession. It can help shape their conduct according to the standards desired in the field, thereby aiding in the development of their professional habits.
These arguments presented by the American Bar Association have gained universal acceptance in today’s legal profession.
Regarding the second part of the question—if ethics are so important, why are they not codified through legislation? The main concern is that codifying such ethics through legislation could restrict the legal profession to a rigid framework, potentially lowering professional standards. There’s also the risk that lawyers may limit themselves to the bare minimum required by law, which—while technically legal—might fall short of ethical expectations. Therefore, adherence to these ethical standards should remain a matter of personal and professional morality rather than legal enforcement. Such rules should be broad, flexible, and easy to understand, not rigid and narrow.
Lawyers engage with various stakeholders such as clients, courts, and the public. Their behavior, thus, cannot be easily confined within a single code. Codifying such ethics is a complex and difficult task and may not be practical.
(B) What are the various enactments that relate to professional ethics?
Various Enactments Relating to Professional Ethics
In ancient India, during the Hindu and Muslim periods, justice was administered by scholars (pundits and maulvis), and there was no recognized profession of advocacy. The profession of law began to emerge when the Regulating Act was introduced, leading to the establishment of the Supreme Courts in Calcutta, Bombay, and Madras. These courts recognized advocacy as an independent profession, requiring lawyers to register with the court.
After the Act of Settlement of 1781, the legal profession took a more defined shape in Indian courts. Since many practicing lawyers were trained in England, they followed the ethical norms of English law. Over time, the legal profession developed further.
In the modern era, several enactments regulate the conduct of legal professionals in India. The main laws governing professional behavior include:
Legal Practitioners Act
Bombay Advocates Act
The Advocates Act, 1961 (Bar Council of India Act)
Other Acts relevant to legal practitioners
These enactments address various aspects of the legal profession. In addition to these, traditional professional values also guide lawyers’ conduct. However, there is no single comprehensive legislation in India that fully codifies the rules of professional ethics for lawyers. This is partly because professional ethics involve moral considerations that go beyond the reach of statutory regulation.
Today, the Indian legal profession is undergoing qualitative changes. These changes are not only in the scale and nature of the profession but also in the perception of law’s purpose and value. Justice impacts the common man, and since lawyers are pillars of the justice delivery system, they must be governed not only by legal rules but also by moral values. A democratic profession must reflect this ethical character.
As society becomes more complex, law inevitably becomes more complex as well. To prevent misuse of these complexities for vested interests, there is a greater need for rules related to professional ethics. The moral armor of a lawyer becomes increasingly significant in such a scenario.
Legal Profession: Meaning, Nature, and Importance
Constitution of India 61. Procedure for impeachment of the President.
What is Appropriation Bill? Defination or meaning
The Appropriation Bill : Definition, Objectives & Benefits.
In conclusion, professional ethics in the legal profession are not merely a formality but a fundamental necessity that helps preserve the sanctity of the justice system and public trust. While codified rules have their limitations, the observance of ethical values remains a moral obligation for every legal professional. Present laws and traditional values together guide lawyers’ behavior, but as legal processes become more complex, there is a pressing need to make professional ethics more practical, clear, and comprehensive—only then can we establish a fair, ethical, and just legal system.